Oscars 2010

Nov 3 2009 12:37 PM ET

Best Actress: A rush of last-minute contenders

Categories: Best Actress

The-Last-Station_lI know that when it comes to scoring an Oscar nomination, it helps to be fresh in voters’ minds, but this is a little ridiculous. In the past few weeks, Oscar-qualifying runs were announced for The Last Station, with Helen Mirren, and The Loss of a Teardrop Diamond, starring Bryce Dallas Howard. And now comes word of a one-week release for the festival drama London River, featuring Brenda Blethyn (who gave what I still believe is one of the best performances ever in Secrets & Lies). Clearly these last-minute moves speak to how sparse the Best Actress race is this year—Julie & Julia’s Meryl Streep, An Education’s Carey Mulligan, and Precious‘ Gabourey Sidibe are likely in, leaving two slots for the taking. But can any of these 11th-hour entries actually make it into the final five? Off the three, I’d give Mirren the edge; her performance as Leo Tolstoy’s wife, Sophia, is fiery and intense, and she’s got Sony Pictures Classics releasing the film. But with other promising contenders yet to be seen (Nine’s Marion Cotillard, The Lovely Bones‘ Saoirse Ronan), scoring a nomination as a last-minute contender is definitely going to be an uphill battle.

Image credit: Stephan Rabold

Comments (1-15) of 76 Add your comment

Page: 1 2 3
  • Jonathan F.

    How about Eva Green or Juno Temple in “Cracks”? Long shot?

  • waytoofriendly

    Agree with you about Brenda Blethyn and Secrets and Lies. Brilliant!

    • t.g. pierson

      Brenda Blethyn in Secrets & Lies was like watching a raw nerve being picked at for two hours. A truly brilliant and heartbreaking performance.

      • paige

        sweethawwwwt!

    • bootsycolumbia

      I’m still kind of bitter that she didn’t win the Oscar for that movie.

      • Anne

        Ditto!

  • Mysterio

    Well, considering that Obama was able to win a peace “prize” (do we still need to pretend that this is a prize?) by doing absolutely nothing, why wouldn’t be be able to win this prize, too?

    • plushpuppy

      Obvious troll is obvious. Do not feed the troll.
      Your troll has failed please report to 4chan right away for trolling 101.

      • jmo

        Ha ha ha. Good one!

  • Chris

    Am I the only one that thought Amy Adams was fantastic in Sunshine Cleaning? Not the best movie, but I thought her performance was great.

    • stiffy

      Yeah, I forgot that ‘Amy Adams’ was fantastic in ‘Sunshine Cleaning’ and deserves a nomination!

      • M Weyer

        Possible but not sure, movie was a while ago and not a wide release. Do see Adams maybe scoring a supporting nod for Julie and Julia as a makeup for last year.

    • Rebecca E.

      Amy Adams was terrific in Sunshine Cleaning, but I think Emily Blunt was just as good.

    • izikavazo

      I thought that technically came out last year.

  • Martin Haro

    You don’t think Maya Rudolph could still surprise come nom time, Dave?
    http://moviemartin.blogspot.com

    • shawshank

      I would be so happy if that happened. She is sooooooo underrated. She says more with an eyebrow raise than most actresses say screaming. Nominate Rudolph (even if the last line of that movie sucks and ruins the moment they built)

    • rob

      I just rented “Away we go” last weekend and while I didn’t love the whole movie, Maya should be nominated. She’s incredible. After the first few minutes I never once felt like I was watching an actress portraying a character–just the character.

    • Jenna

      I would be thrilled if Maya got a nom for Away We Go! Great emotional performance!

      • mazie beth

        I’d be happy to see Away We Go nominated period. one of the best comedies I’ve seen all year.

    • Rebecca E.

      Man, did I love Maya Rudolph in “Away We Go.” It came completely out of left field for me. Who knew she could act that well? I also thought John Krasinski gave an exceptional performance.

  • Laura

    What about Abbie Cornish in “Bright Star”? I think she is definitely a sure bet for a nomination.

    • Taylor

      I don’t think she is a sure bet at all. In fact, I think her performance is overrated, as is the movie. She was fine, but nothing award worthy going on there.

      • E.

        I thought Abbie Cornish gave a lovely, humane, interesting performance in Bright Star–the scenes where she’s stricken with grief over being parted from Keats capture the raw feelings of first love so well, without going overboard into melodrama. But I worry that the movie didn’t make enough of an impression at the box office for her to have a real shot at a nomination. Too bad… she definitely feels like a star in the making to me.

    • Alan of Montreal

      yeah, I was surprised she wasn’t mentioned in the article either. Every Oscar site I’ve seen has her up there in the top 5 right now.

  • Troy

    If Sony Picture Classics hurrys up and releases Mother & Child, Annette Bening can also be tossed into the mix… otherwise, the Oscar is hers in 2011!

    • thirdman

      I think if that is the case, then they should wait to release it so she has the oscar.

      • paige

        at least we know she wont be losing to Hilary Swank this year– Amelia did HORRIBLE

  • jfms777

    All fine actresses. But one thing is true. Meryl. Meryl. Meryl.

    • John

      Barring an upset, I could see Julie and Julia being the movie/role where the Academy just finally says “Enough already! Just give it to Meryl!”

      • Sparky

        Meryl has nt won an oscar yet???

      • Diggity

        She’s won 2- one best actress and one supporting. But considering how amazing she is and how many times she’s been nominated, thats a crime.

  • T

    What about Sandra Bullock for The Blind Side. The movie looks promising and hopefully the movie is awesome. I love those kind of movies. Who knows who well be nominated we’ll have to see.

    • izikavazo

      It wouldn’t be bad if it got nominated, but it seems like these movies don’t get nominated anymore.

  • stiffy

    Tilda Swinton in ‘Julia’ was riveting.
    Isabelle Fuhrman in ‘The Orphan’.
    Meryl Streep should be ’supporting’ and she’d win, but not for Best Actress in “Julia and Julie”.

  • Mary

    I’d love to see a nom for Melanie Laurent from “Inglourious Basterds,” but they’ll probably stick her in the Supporting category.

    • davey

      I kinda hope the studio does campaign her in SUPPORTING….she might sneak in for that category…but it would be a very long uphill battle for a nom in the LEAD actress race. She was wonderful though, wasn’t she?

  • sgs

    Oh, what about Gwyneth Paltrow in ‘Two Lovers’. I thought she was exceptional as the dysfunctional troubled heartbreaker to J. Phoenix.

    • E.

      Agreed, but this movie is so forgotten! Too bad, I thought it was an unusually serious picture about the psychology of love, and Gwyneth gave her best performance in ages.

    • Jackson Tolk

      If anyone from Two Lovers is nominated it would be Isabella Rossellini. That scene with Joaquin in the stairwell near the end of the film was heartbreaking.

  • Davidsask

    I agree with someone posted earlier that young actress who starred in Orphan deserves some buzz at very least! May and Amy although in box office losers put in great acting roles!

  • KyleS

    I think it’ll be….

    Carey
    Saoirse
    Gabourey
    Meryl

    …and Marion and Helen fighting over the last spot when its all said and done.

  • justin

    I agree with whoever said Melanie Laurant should be nominated. I thought out of everyone in that movie, along with Christophe Waltz, she gave one of the best performances and NEEDS to be recognized.

Page: 1 2 3

Add your comment

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Advertisement
Powered by WordPress.com VIP